Desk Chair Options (Sitting, Standing, or Kneeling)

Alternatives to Using a Chair at a Desk

Sorry to say, however sitting could also be worse for you than donuts. Fortunately there are many wholesome alternate options to the trendy day workplace chair. With so many choices to select from although, which desk chair alternate options are greatest?

The Penalties of Sitting

Earlier than I get into alternate options for desk chairs, it helps to know why I might advocate staying away from the widespread workplace chair. Sitting has been dubbed the brand new smoking, and researchers have discovered it has some fairly unlucky well being results. Dangers for situations like weight problems, diabetes, most cancers and coronary heart illness (to call a couple of) all enormously improve the longer we sit.

For many who sit at a desk all day, even common exercises aren’t sufficient to counteract the ailing results. Sitting for hours on finish shaves about twice the break day of our lives than smoking does. In reality, some analysis reveals that people who smoke had higher well being markers than different staff as a result of they obtained as much as transfer each few hours! This isn’t excellent news for these of us who spend a number of time engaged on a pc or at a desk.

In a single survey, almost half of workplace employees didn’t really feel comfy at their workstations. Extended sitting has been linked with exhaustion, hypertension, and musculoskeletal points within the shoulders, decrease again, thighs, and knees.

Desk chair alternate options may help to alleviate these points for a extra comfy work day.

Standing Isn’t Sufficient

So if the issue is sitting, then the answer is standing, proper? Perhaps not. One examine of over 7,300 staff discovered that those that stood for his or her jobs had double the danger of coronary heart illness than those that principally sat. It seems that it isn’t essentially the sitting or the standing however the lack of motion and selection.

One of the best outcomes had been seen when the staff utilized standing, sitting, and strolling at totally different instances all through their work day. Motion and selection are key right here!

Why Desk Chair Options Are More healthy

It’s fairly clear that sitting for lengthy durations is dangerous, so the answer could also be to not sit in any respect. The next desk chair alternate options give all kinds of choices to fulfill totally different wants. They permit the physique to remain in movement (some greater than others), and in addition assist the pelvis keep a correct tilt for good spinal alignment. At our home, we’ve a mix of those, together with a mini-trampoline in our classroom in order that none of us are sitting for a chronic period of time.

Kneeling Chair

Whereas they might look a bit odd, kneeling chairs serve a wholesome goal. A kneeling chair takes the burden off of the hips and helps enhance and forestall hip joint points. A examine with 20 contributors discovered that kneeling chairs helped the decrease backbone to remain in alignment higher than an everyday workplace chair. (Word if going this route, researchers in one other examine discovered that the perfect knee angle when sitting in a kneeling chair was 135 levels.)

Backside Line

Some folks could discover that this chair works nicely for assuaging and stopping spinal points. Others nonetheless could discover the design cumbersome to get out and in of. That is the kneeling chair I’ve.

Saddle Seat

A saddle seat is a minimalistic chair that forces customers to have higher posture by eliminating a again to lean in opposition to. One small examine discovered that those that sat in a saddle seat had higher posture and fewer decrease again ache, however hip and buttocks ache was worse. Curiously, a comparability of chairs on this examine confirmed it didn’t matter which chair was used — muscle groups tended to get sore anyway, simply perhaps in several areas of the physique.

One other examine discovered that sitting on a saddle chair improved decrease again and pelvis alignment, however customers additionally tended to compensate by jutting their necks out additional … not perfect. Not one of the chairs in contrast within the examine had been good throughout the board, however the saddle chair carried out higher than each the workplace chair and kneeling chair when it got here to correct spinal alignment.

Backside Line

A saddle seat may help enhance decrease again posture and alleviate ache. Nonetheless, sitting in a saddle stool for too lengthy may cause muscle fatigue and ache. This one appears to be a fairly good possibility.

Steadiness Stools

Numerous totally different chairs match into this class, however the premise is similar. These backless chairs, or stools, function an unstable seat that consistently prompts customers to keep up physique stability. These stools are just like yoga balls in that they tilt and swivel at a number of angles for an energetic sitting expertise. A examine evaluating a number of chair choices discovered that the stability stool helped promote higher neck alignment in comparison with the opposite seats.

Backside Line

Steadiness stools assist to have interaction the core and encourage energetic sitting. Many stability stools aren’t top adjustable, so they might not match a specific top or desk for correct alignment. Some folks could discover the fixed minute actions distracting from their duties. I discover that youngsters love these and we’ve personally tried (and preferred) these:

Yoga, Stability, or Train Ball

Train balls (often known as yoga or stability balls) have been round because the 1960s however now they’re changing into standard particularly in workplace settings. Like stability stools, they encourage energetic sitting and are thought to have interaction the core and different muscle groups. The outcomes are a bit extra combined on this desk chair different although.

A number of research have proven that sitting on an train ball doesn’t expend extra vitality than an everyday workplace chair. Different analysis has proven that trunk movement and lumbar motion had been larger within the train ball group. Nonetheless, the identical group additionally skilled considerably extra spinal compression.

Begin out Sluggish

A small examine of 14 folks sitting on train balls discovered muscle activation minimal and the seat uncomfortable after an prolonged time. In a special examine, those that slowly transitioned from an workplace chair to a ball skilled decreased again ache in comparison with those that simply jumped proper in. This appears to point that an train ball may be useful, however customers ought to begin out gradual.

Discovering the Proper Train Ball

To regulate the peak the ball may be deflated a bit, and totally different sizes can be found for folks with totally different heights. Some train balls are weighted or have sand on the backside to maintain them from rolling throughout a room once you rise up.

Backside Line

An train ball may be useful and encourage energetic sitting, however it could take a bit extra concentrated effort transferring round on it to reap the advantages. Some folks could discover this feature a bit too unstable, cumbersome or uncomfortable for them. That is one which we’ve used.

Train or Yoga Ball Chair

This selection affords the advantages of an train ball, however with a bit extra to it. For the reason that ball is resting in a body it may well’t roll away however continues to be bouncy sufficient to supply some motion. There’s a small backrest to forestall fatigue for many who want a bit extra assist. It’s additionally rather less cumbersome for many who can’t comfortably match a full measurement train ball into their workplace house. The wheels on the underside making transferring across the workplace simpler, too.

Backside Line

Whereas this desk chair different affords lots of the similar advantages as an train ball, it could not enable sufficient core motion to actually interact muscle groups. Nonetheless, it could be a superb compromise for these seeking to have the assist of an workplace chair with the bounce of an train ball.

Bicycle Desk

In contrast to a few of the different desk chair alternate options, a motorbike desk requires considerably extra muscle movement. One examine confirmed that bike desks assist to burn fats and improve work engagement with out negatively effecting cognition and work efficiency. Research contributors cycled about 98 minutes per week, in order that they weren’t even energetic the entire time to see constructive outcomes.

Different research have noticed the next advantages of motorcycle desks:

  • Typing duties and quick time period reminiscence not adversely affected
  • Response instances that required consideration improved
  • Higher consideration and work efficiency
  • Extra motivation
  • Extra vitality and a sense of higher well being
  • Elevated typing pace with out growing typing errors

Backside Line

Bike desks could be a good possibility for people who have the house since customers are reaping the advantages of actively exercising. Some folks could discover the biking distracting or dislike the sitting place for sure work duties. Right here’s an honest one to take a look at.

Standing Desk

Standing desks are a preferred possibility obtainable from most shops. A number of years in the past, even a few of the White Home workers transitioned to standing desks.

Surprisingly, standing desks have a protracted historical past. It’s been stated that well-known males like Thomas Jefferson, Charles Dickens, and Leonardo Da Vinci all utilized standing desks. Vintage standing desks from the 18th and 19th century may be discovered at sure vintage shops.

One examine discovered that those that stood extra for work had decrease cortisol ranges and decreased stress than those that sat. Different analysis has discovered that standing affords extra physique motion than chairs that had been alleged to encourage energetic sitting.

Some standing desks stay at a snug standing top, whereas others additionally convert to suit a seated place. I favor desks like this to boost and decrease from sitting to standing (or to regulate if a couple of particular person works there) on the contact of a button. A sit/stand desk affords the advantages of standing, but in addition permits a break for fatigued legs.

Backside Line

I really like my standing desk (with treadmill possibility) as a result of I felt it was a greater possibility for me than a chair. I like that I can get some extra motion in and the children aren’t tall sufficient to succeed in my pc and different  gadgets on the desk. The draw back to a standing desk although is that it may well trigger varicose veins and again pressure if used for too lengthy with out transferring round so it is very important stroll or use a wobble stool a few of the time.

Treadmill Desks

Treadmill desks supply the advantages of standing, however pair it with extra motion for elevated advantages. It could actually assist decrease cortisol ranges, discourage weight acquire from a sedentary life-style, and enhance general well being.

Some folks fear that strolling could also be too distracting, however the tempo could be very gradual. A examine evaluating treadmill desk customers to these sitting in an everyday workplace chair discovered that each teams had the identical pace and accuracy on cognitive exams. One other examine discovered that those that use a treadmill desk didn’t carry out as nicely at typing and different duties that examined consideration, studying, and reminiscence. Regardless of that, the bodily and stress-relieving advantages could make it a worthwhile possibility for some.

Backside Line

Treadmill desks will not be the best choice for everybody although I really like mine and it’s what I exploit when recording The Wholesome Mothers Podcast. Those that do photograph modifying, graphic design, and different duties that require a gentle hand could discover the strolling too jolting. It’s perfect to have a treadmill that has a desk over it, as a substitute of hooked up, since this makes the workspace extra steady whereas strolling.

Which desk chair alternate options have you ever tried? Does one among these choices sound like the precise match to your workspace? Share under!

Sources

1. Gregory DE, Dunk NM, Callaghan JP. Stability ball versus workplace chair: comparability of muscle activation and lumbar backbone posture throughout extended sitting. Hum Components. 2006;48(1):142-53.
2. Daneshmandi H, Choobineh A, Ghaem H, Karimi M. Antagonistic Results of Extended Sitting Habits on the Normal Well being of Workplace Staff. J Life-style Med. 2017;7(2):69-75.
three. Smith P, Ma H, Glazier RH, Gilbert-ouimet M, Mustard C. The Relationship Between Occupational Standing and Sitting and Incident Coronary heart Illness Over a 12-12 months Interval in Ontario, Canada. Am J Epidemiol. 2017.
four. Díaz-martínez X, Steell L, Martinez MA, et al. Larger ranges of self-reported sitting time is related to greater threat of kind 2 diabetes unbiased of bodily exercise in Chile. J Public Well being (Oxf). 2017.
5. Grooten WJ, Äng BO, Hagströmer M, Conradsson D, Nero H, Franzén E. Does a dynamic chair improve workplace employees’ actions? – Outcomes from a mixed laboratory and area examine. Appl Ergon. 2017;60:1-11.
6. Gadge Okay, Innes E. An investigation into the instant results on consolation, productiveness and posture of the Bambach saddle seat and an ordinary workplace chair. Work. 2007;29(three):189-203.
7. Jackson JA, Banerjee-guénette P, Gregory DE, Callaghan JP. Ought to we be extra on the ball? The efficacy of lodging coaching on lumbar backbone posture, muscle exercise, and perceived discomfort throughout stability ball sitting. Hum Components. 2013;55(6):1064-76.
eight. Tudor-locke C, Schuna JM, Frensham LJ, Proenca M. Altering the best way we work: elevating vitality expenditure with workstation alternate options. Int J Obes (Lond). 2014;38(6):755-65.
9. Marks CR, Hylland KE, Terrell J. Stability Ball Sitting versus Chair Sitting Throughout Sub-maximal Arm Ergometry. Int J Exerc Sci. 2012;5(1):16-25.
10. Truszczy?ska-Baszak A, Drza?-Grabiec J. The influence of saddle chairs on spinal curvatures. Work. 2017;57(four):627-633.
11. Babaei H, Razeghi M, Choobineh A, Pakshir H, Rajaeifard A, Rezaian J. A brand new technique for calculating saddle seat top with an emphasis on optimum posture based mostly on trigonometric relations. Int J Occup Saf Ergon. 2016;22(four):565-571.
12. Annetts S, Coales P, Colville R, et al. A pilot investigation into the consequences of various workplace chairs on spinal angles. Eur Backbone J. 2012;21 Suppl 2:S165-70.
13. Gilson ND, Corridor C, Renton A, Ng N, Von hippel W. Do Sitting, Standing, or Treadmill Desks Influence Psychobiological Indicators of Work Productiveness?. J Phys Act Well being. 2017;14(10):793-796.
14. Larson MJ, Lecheminant JD, Carbine Okay, et al. Sluggish strolling on a treadmill desk doesn’t negatively have an effect on government talents: an examination of cognitive management, battle adaptation, response inhibition, and post-error slowing. Entrance Psychol. 2015;6:723.
15. Larson MJ, Lecheminant JD, Hill Okay, Carbine Okay, Masterson T, Christenson E. Cognitive and typing outcomes measured concurrently with gradual treadmill strolling or sitting: implications for treadmill desks. PLoS ONE. 2015;10(four):e0121309.
16. Torbeyns T, De geus B, Bailey S, et al. Bike Desks within the Workplace: Bodily Well being, Cognitive Operate, Work Engagement, and Work Efficiency. J Occup Environ Med. 2016;58(12):1257-1263.
17. Torbeyns T, De geus B, Bailey S, et al. Biking on a Bike Desk Positively Influences Cognitive Efficiency. PLoS ONE. 2016;11(11):e0165510.
18. Van houcke J, Schouten A, Steenackers G, Vandermeulen D, Pattyn C, Audenaert EA. Laptop-based estimation of the hip joint response pressure and hip flexion angle in three totally different sitting configurations. Appl Ergon. 2017;63:99-105.
19. Bettany-saltikov J, Warren J, Jobson M. Ergonomically designed kneeling chairs are they price it? : Comparability of sagittal lumbar curvature in two totally different seating postures. Stud Well being Technol Inform. 2008;140:103-6.
20. Kingma I, Van dieën JH. Static and dynamic postural loadings throughout pc work in females: Sitting on an workplace chair versus sitting on an train ball. Appl Ergon. 2009;40(2):199-205.
21. Koren Okay, Pišot R, Šimuni. B. Lively workstation permits workplace employees to work effectively whereas sitting and exercising reasonably. Appl Ergon. 2016;54:83-9.

Comments

comments